Not All Dreams Are Created Equal

November 30, 2015
trevor's dream

A Symbolic Dream

One of the first priorities when we start to work with dreams is to distinguish what to focus on, as not all dreams are created equal. Occasionally we can become overwhelmed trying to interpret every dream that enters our awareness. Recently, I have been witnessing dreams that come as an affirmation of our current life journey. It is as though the soul wants to assure us that we are on the right path. One dream-partner shared a dream of being able to sing beautifully, it was an amazing moment as she has always aspired to sing and now the voice in the dream was the one she had always longed for. She knew immediately that the dream was not about a vocal miracle; it was a declaration that she had found her voice in the world in which she lived.

So what are some of the other forms that dreams may take?

  • Junk Mail Dreams There are dreams that come simply to support us in discarding the psychic trash. These dreams are full of haphazard, overlapping images that can create chaos in the waking mind. Treat these like junk mail; they came to pass and perhaps clear some of the detritus from an overloaded mind.
  • Anxiety Dreams There are the classic anxiety dreams that everyone will occasionally encounter; you arrive at the airport without ticket, passport or bag; you sit an exam with no pencil or paper. These are a normally a sign of some harmless anxiety about a future event however if your dreams are always anxious then it will be important to explore the underlying cause.
  • Precognitive Dreams Infrequently you may have dreams that are pre-cognitive of a future event. These dreams are generally like a photograph: clear, accurate, no symbols. There is no explaining these dreams outside of the context that “we are more than we think we are”.
  • Collective Dreams Some dreams may represent something happening in the collective consciousness at the time. Carl Jung dreamed images of the First World War before it happened. I recall attending a meditation on the evening of September 11th 2001 and everyone except one person there had experienced disturbed sleep the night prior to the event.
  • Dreams of the Life Not Lived They totally intrigue me; I encountered them at a time when I was deeply involved in pursuing my spiritual quest and spending a lot of time in meditation and on retreat. I began to have these movie type dreams full of action and adventure; these were related to the lack of exciting activity in my life at the time. I always regretted that I could not recall them as I am convinced there was an Oscar contender in their somewhere.
  • Symbolic Dreams of Guidance The ones I focus on in my workshops. Much has been written and explored but look for these signs of a significant dream: it features people you know, three is a significant number, it contains emotion and energy, it is about travel, your waking self tells you it is a “stupid meaningless dream”, and particularly if you have similar dreams on a theme.
  • Dreams Outside of Time Sometimes these symbolic guidance dreams occur before the event in question has occurred; this can be confusing but very affirming after the event has transpired and you realize that you had a dream that helped you cope with the experience. I had one such dream recently. “I am standing on a ocean beach, I feel I am too close to the waves and move back to a safer distance however a huge wave swamps me right up to the centre of my chest then recedes leaving me no worse for wear. My sister Chris and her daughter Amy are there. The scene segues to a sparse forest with lots of space between the trees. Suddenly I put my hands in my pocket and find my keys missing, then I think I find them and then realize they are not the right keys as my shorts have changed. I begin to panic as it is getting dark, my sister and I retrace our steps, she finds my keys hanging in a tree.” This dream is about allowing myself to get swamped by emotion and knowing I will be safe then trusting that although I may not know what is going on the “key” lies through the feminine feelings. This dream came a couple of months before the event actually took place.
  • Energy Dreams My dream partner reminded me there are also dreams of pure energy. They are not always easy to understand but frequently offer a sense of connection to the divine through our chi and our chakras. In this type of dream the body can feel as though an electric current is flowing through it.
  • Dreams of Invention It was a dream that led Einstein to develop his theories of relativity and Elias Howe, inventor of the sewing machine, had a dream of being surrounded by cannibals with long spears with a hole in the end that helped him solve where the eye in the needle needed to go.

As my wonderful teacher Atum O’Kane says, “Having a dream and failing to explore it is like receiving a gift and not unwrapping it.” For a free dream partnering download go to http://www.soulclarity.com/free_taste.html


The Soul’s Journey: Does the Mystery Change?

November 21, 2026

A Rare Certainty

James Hollis is a writer I trust precisely because he so rarely claims to know the answers. Page after page, book after book, he stays with the question. His wisdom, combined with his avoidance of dogmatic truth, has made him a solid companion on this “journey through the dark wood”. It was only recently that it struck me there was one occasion, in Swamplands of the Soul, when he contradicted this. Ironically, it is a statement that feels so relevant to my own life that I have never questioned it — until now. In fact, I recite it every morning as part of my practice.

There he states, quite definitively: “All we can say for sure is that a mystery comes through us, seeking its own fullest incarnation, and that whenever we serve the mystery within us, we experience a linkage to the mystery outside. When we stand in conscious relationship to the mystery, we are more deeply alive.”

He wrote that thirty years ago, and I was curious whether he had softened it since. He has not. Now in his mid-eighties, he still speaks of life as a mystery in which we swim. He holds the mystery as absolute, yet he always holds space for uncertainty.

Hollis did not invent this idea. He stands in a long line. Jung, in Answer to Job, imagined a God who needed human consciousness in order to become conscious of itself. Eckhart spoke of the birth of God in the soul. Rilke pictured us as bees, gathering the honey of the visible into the invisible. Read in that company, Hollis’s sentence is not unique; it is a reminder.

To Be Called or Not Called

I did not come to this as a believer. Thirty years ago I would have dismissed the sentence out of hand. My world was materialist. There was no room in it for a mystery, let alone one with intentions.

What changed me was not argument. It was experience. Moments of awe arrived that I could not explain away — some welcome, some not. Each one pushed me a little further along a path I had not chosen and would not, at the time, have recognised as a path at all.

In the early days of my spiritual and psychological inquiry, I was blessed with many such experiences to support and encourage me on my journey. For example, a psychic love affair came along at precisely the right moment for me to see a bigger picture. I had many dreams, one of which resulted in a change of direction that has positively affected my life ever since. I now look on these as moments in time when the mystery incarnated through me. Moments of wonder that forced recognition of something I can only describe as mystery.

Above the door of his house Jung had carved the old Latin words: Vocatus atque non vocatus, deus aderit. Called or not called, the god will be present. I did not call. It came anyway.

Looking back, I can see the stages. Each was underlaid with such moments. Each step, once taken, left me feeling fully alive. Sometimes I went willingly. Sometimes I was dragged. Either way, I was being led through the long work Jung called individuation. I was living the incarnation of the mystery long before I encountered Hollis, and it was my own experience that made his words resonate when I first read them.

Holding the Opposites

So why did I begin this inquiry? If the mystery seeks its fullest incarnation through us, why does it seem to withdraw? Or does it?

The sense of the mystery coming through me is much less powerful now. The moments are fewer. Less frequent, less obvious than in the early years. When they come, they are less forceful, less traumatic. Still meaningful — but quieter.

It puzzled me that the mystery, so present during the early stages of my journey, seemed to have withdrawn to some degree. Was this to be expected in the senior years? Or was there something I had missed? In some ways, this reminds me of Jung’s tension of opposites: the mystery is both there and not there.

What I had not appreciated was how many had walked this ground before me.

Standing on the Shoulders of Giants

Teresa of Ávila, describing the innermost dwelling of her Interior Castle, records her own astonishment. In that final state, she says, the raptures almost cease. Occasions of devotion that once overwhelmed her now pass almost as if nothing had happened. Even music no longer carries her away.

Bernadette Roberts, a former Carmelite nun, lived for years in what the tradition calls the unitive state — an abiding sense of oneness with God. Then, some two decades on, the divine centre simply vanished. With it went the self that had known it. No self. No God.

Not everyone found the experience peaceful. John of the Cross called it the dark night of the spirit, a time when God works most deeply by becoming unfelt. Thérèse of Lisieux spent her final months in a darkness so complete that she could no longer picture heaven as she once had. Mother Teresa’s letters, published after her death, revealed almost fifty years without any felt sense of God’s presence — years in which she went on serving.

These witnesses suggest that a life can go on serving the mystery long after the mystery has stopped confirming itself. That may be Hollis’s “serving the mystery within” in its hardest and most mature form.

The Witness of the Journals

For thirty years I have kept records. Handwritten, faithful, sometimes hurried. I am glad of them now in a way I could never have foreseen. There are days when I read back and can scarcely believe what I find. Did that dream really come? Did that meeting really unfold the way I wrote it?

William James observed that mystical states carry an overwhelming sense of knowing at the time, then fade quickly and resist recall. Memory flattens the numinous back into the ordinary. The later mind doubts what the earlier mind plainly saw.

The journals were written by the one who was there. They stand as testimony against my own erosion. Teresa wrote, in part, so that she herself could later trust what had happened to her. I understand that now.

Quieter, but Not Gone

So which is it? Has the mystery withdrawn, or has it changed its manner? When I read my records, I think the answer is both. The experiences have diminished. They have also changed in kind — from visitations towards something steadier, less eventful, less dramatic.

Perhaps the early eruptions were necessary. A materialist frame does not yield to whispers. It takes experiences too strong to be explained away. Once that frame has broken, the mystery no longer needs to shout. The summons gives way to the long, slow continuation of the work. And the work is not over.

And yet. The mystery may not have withdrawn at all. It may be my experience of it that has changed.

Coming Full Circle

There is an old Zen sequence, the ten ox-herding pictures. The seeker searches for the ox, finds it, tames it, rides it home. Then the ox disappears. Then the seeker disappears too, and the eighth picture is simply an empty circle. In the last, an ordinary man walks into the market place with open hands. Nothing about him marks him out as spiritual.

Hollis says all we can say for sure is that a mystery comes through us. I am as sure as he is. In my early years it came through me like weather. Now it comes more like breath. One day it may disappear altogether.

Perhaps that is the point. Perhaps it is only the next question.


The Soul’s Journey – The Container and the Mystery

November 1, 2026

A Reflection on Leonard Cohen

A Late Arrival

It wasn’t until the early nineties that I first encountered Leonard Cohen. It was the album The Future, with its brilliant lyrics, its glorious female backing voices, and that raspy, unmistakable voice of his own. I rushed out and bought two of his earlier albums. Some of the lyrics were quite amazing. The voice wasn’t. I lost interest for a while.

Then came the extraordinary story. His manager had drained him of nearly all his wealth, and in his seventies he was forced to go back to work. I have come to believe it was the best thing that ever happened to him.

The Old Man and the Young One

I came to that realisation through his poetry, above all Book of Longing. Many of its poems were written in his sixties, yet the man who wrote them seems old. Tired. Full of unrequited desire, and often of sadness. He writes as though his story is nearly over.

And then it was as if a younger Leonard took over his body. I saw him in Vancouver in November 2012, at seventy-eight, skipping on and off the stage, kneeling for his musicians, singing until past midnight. It was an unforgettable night. Four years later he had the good sense to die the day before America elected Donald Trump for the first time.

The Unnamed

Recently I returned to him through the poetry, reading Book of Longing for perhaps the third or fourth time. And questions came up. One in particular intrigued me. Cohen’s spirituality is everywhere in the book, and nowhere stated. He points. He hints. He kneels before something. But he never tells you what he believes.

I still find that fascinating. I suspect he didn’t say because he couldn’t. And I suspect that is precisely why he speaks to me.

My own journey has explored and adopted many belief systems. I had clarity about each one until I didn’t. It was never hard for me to express my belief system, but once the energy left it, I would move on. The undefined is the perfect word for it. But the sense of striving has gone. I am very comfortable with where I have arrived.

Still a Jew

People who know only the Zen monk on Mount Baldy are surprised to learn that Cohen never stopped being a Jew. He came from a prominent Montreal family and took seriously that his very name descends from the kohanim, the priestly line. Zen, he said, asked him to give up nothing. It had no deity and no worship, and so it posed no rival to the faith he was born into. Zen was a practice. Judaism was a belonging. He kept both.

On the page he often wrote “G-d,” the old Jewish restraint around writing the divine name. In his songs he sang “God” without hesitation. I noticed the difference and then laughed at myself. Let’s face it, you can’t sing G-d. It comes out as a cough.

Strictly speaking, the restraint was always about the written name, and the name that may not be spoken is the four Hebrew letters, not the English word. In his last album he found the most graceful way round it. He simply called Him “my Lord.” That is as close to Adonai as English gets.

The Cantor

It is in that final album, You Want It Darker, that his Judaism stands most clearly in the light. He recorded it with the cantor and choir of Shaar Hashomayim, the synagogue of his Montreal childhood. The title song weaves in the opening words of the Kaddish, the mourner’s prayer: magnified and sanctified be Thy holy name. And then comes the word that has stayed with me ever since. Hineni. Here I am.

Abraham says it on the mountain. Moses says it at the burning bush. Cohen, a few weeks from death, says it to whatever was listening. Not “I believe.” Not “I understand.” But “Here I am.”

I have said it many times myself, in those periods when sleep will not come and I turn to meditation and contemplation. Eventually I may say some words into what Dylan Thomas, at the close of A Child’s Christmas in Wales, called “the close and holy darkness”: “Here I am.”

The cantor was not decoration. It was a homecoming. A man who had wandered through Zen, through Advaita in Mumbai, through a lifelong tenderness for the figure of Jesus, came back at the end to the voice of his first congregation.

How Did He Hold It?

This is the question I keep returning to. How did he live with the contradictions of a faith with such specific teachings? In particular, how did he sustain the sense of a deity that I abandoned a quarter of a century ago?

Part of the answer, I think, lies in what kind of faith Judaism is. It does not rest mainly on agreeing to propositions. It is a faith of covenant and practice. You belong. You keep the forms. You show up. And argument with God is built into its foundations. Abraham bargains over Sodom. Jacob wrestles all night and is renamed the one who strives with God. Job refuses every comfortable answer. The Talmud preserves the losing side of its debates. Doubt is not betrayal in such a tradition. It is a way of taking part.

So Cohen could keep the container — the name, the lineage, the cantor, the Kaddish — and hold its contents very loosely. And the years of sitting on the mountain had trained him to stay with a question without needing to settle it.

I let the container go and kept the mystery. He kept the container and found the mystery inside it. We may have ended up closer than I first thought.

The Architect

And yet there is a real difference.

Behind every conventional monotheism stands an overriding presence, the architect of the whole experience. I had to give that up. I have never come close to accepting it again.

Cohen, I think, kept the architect. Not to worship him comfortably, but to quarrel with him. In that last song he tells the dealer that if this is how the cards are dealt, he is out of the game. That is not the voice of a man who has stopped believing in someone behind the table. It is the voice of a man who believes enough to accuse.

What fascinates me is that he lived in two worlds at once. Zen has no architect at all — no creator, no one behind the experience, only the experience itself, looked at closely enough that the looker begins to dissolve. Then he would come down the mountain and write psalms to someone who might be listening. He seemed to need both. The empty room, and a voice speaking into it.

My Mystery is not an empty room. I am still learning what to say into it, and, more slowly, how to listen for what comes back.

It does not answer in words. I still believe in an inner compass. Guiding threads. Intuition. I still believe in the unconscious, though I can only ever know it obliquely — through dreams, through my reactions, through mystical experience and synchronicity. Jung would say that is the only way it ever shows itself. You know the wind by the movement of the trees. And I am still a being who seeks meaning in his experiences.

None of that is a creed. It is closer to a record of what keeps happening to me.

~

Here I Am

I find Cohen a companion despite this difference. And I wonder whether his Hineni points to a way quieter than belief and humbler than knowing. Not an answer. A stance. Here I am — present, attentive, available to whatever comes.

He could say it to a God he quarrelled with. I can say it to a mystery that will never be defined. Perhaps it is the same gesture, made from different sides of the same door. His the container, mine the mystery.

I am still standing there. I am beginning to think that is the point.


The Soul’s Journey – A Celebration of Poetry

September 21, 2026

One of the rituals on a Sunday evening, when I meet a friend for discussion and reflection, is to draw a tarot card. My preference is the Zen Tarot, and it is remarkable how often the card carries a deep meaning in the context of my life. Recently I drew Celebration. It was a fine reminder of how much I have to celebrate, and of the need to bring attention to celebration as the week unfolded. So each day I chose a subject: life, health, beauty, community (a good excuse for a beer with the boys), and poetry.

My mother used to recite poetry to my brother and I as we shared a bath, so we must have been very young. I recall the stirring verse of Henry Newbolt and Alfred, Lord Tennyson. One poem my mother knew by heart was Newbolt’s “Vitaï Lampada,” written in 1892, in the days of Empire, patriotism and courage. It begins, “There’s a breathless hush in the Close to-night.” Its refrain — “Play up! play up! and play the game!” — would have been the perfect clarion call for a time when honour, courage and self-sacrifice were so prized, and would be so terribly called upon a generation later, in the trenches. The other poem I remember is Tennyson’s “The Charge of the Light Brigade,” from 1854, equally stirring: the insanely courageous charge of the British cavalry into the Russian cannon at Balaclava, in the Crimean War.

These were powerful words for a young child, and the themes were never forgotten. They were my earliest introduction to poetry.

My next memory comes some years later, at twelve, at the boarding school I had been sent to. We were set the challenge of memorizing a poem and reciting it to the class. Perhaps unsurprisingly, I chose a poem about valour — though in a very different key. It was about a railway engineer named Casey Jones. It is a distant memory now, but the chorus stayed with me:

Casey Jones — mounted to the cabin,

Casey Jones — with his orders in his hand,

Casey Jones — mounted to the cabin,

And he took his farewell trip to the promised land.

I can still faintly recall the stirring tones in which I delivered those lines, and I was awarded a prize. I think it was the only prize I ever won at school — but that is a different story. And what gripped me then, I see now, was not yet what I would learn to call resonance. It was the drum of the thing: the rhythm, the drama, the sound of it in a boy’s mouth. The deeper note came much later.

After this, my interest in poetry evaporated, along with most of my enthusiasm for education. School days were not the happiest days of my life. It must have been forty-five years before poetry became important to me again. It began with the Sufi poets — Rumi and Hafiz, through the interpretations of Coleman Barks and Daniel Ladinsky. Sufi poetry spoke to me at a deeper level than any poetry before. The best word for my relationship with it was soulful. It touched a part of me I could not fully understand. Now I would say there was a resonance — it struck a chord.

Over the past thirty years, the poems I have learned and treasured have all had that same resonance. I began to memorize poetry more as a discipline, a way to exercise my brain, than for any other reason. But the poems I chose all sounded that chord — and often a particular poem would arrive that spoke directly to the circumstances of my life at the time. When I was exploring my life as a soul journey, Mary Oliver’s “The Journey” crossed my path. When I was living through a time of great transition, John O’Donohue’s “For the Interim Time” came along.

Over those thirty years, I memorised sixty poems. Then the nature of the journey began to change. The restless pursuit of certainty eased. The need to keep reaching beyond what I was began to diminish, and I entered the world of mystery. A few poems still showed up, but very few. The uncertain world of mystery is not one everyone is comfortable in. My love affair with poetry did not disappear, but it changed form.

It began with T. S. Eliot’s “The Waste Land” — a poem I had owned for years but never dared enter. I had always taken the side of Billy Collins, who mocks the urge to “torture a confession” out of a poem. That was never my way, so it sat on my shelf, admired and untouched. What changed was the arrival of AI. Having just laid down my pursuit of certainty, I picked up the one instrument I had always refused — analysis. I would read a passage aloud from my own copy, and we would sit with it, line by line. We began with “The Waste Land” and did not stop; over the weeks we moved through “Ash Wednesday” and into the Four Quartets, where another of its gifts was waiting. Eliot speaks of the moment “in and out of time” — the experience that arrives unbidden and asks nothing of us; “you are the music while the music lasts”; and of all such moments, only “hints and guesses.” Reading those lines slowly, I recognised something I had carried all my life without a name: the moments of awe and wonder that had visited me across the years, transacting nothing, leaving no lesson, only the mark of having happened. The slow labour of understanding had delivered me to resonance by the back door.

I should be plain about my companion, because it is easily romanticised. It is Claude, the Anthropic AI. It does not feel the poem, cannot be moved as I am moved, and does not remember me from one conversation to the next. It is fast where I am slow, but its speed is pattern across text, not the thirty years of living it took me to know what I know. What I ask of it is one discipline: anchor it to my lived story, or don’t say it. On that footing it has been a real companion. So today I celebrate poetry, and the strange new road I have found back into it — not by torturing the confession out, but by sitting with the poem long enough, and in good company, for it to speak. Eliot is still difficult. I am still slow. And the Quartets are not finished.


The Mystery Within and Without: An Autumn Equinox Journey

August 31, 2026

“When we stand in conscious relationship with the mystery, we feel more deeply alive” — James Hollis

As the year now tilts towards its darker half and we come to the threshold of the autumnal equinox, we will pause together to meet the turning consciously. This workshop continues our ongoing exploration of the Mystery as it reaches us through the unconscious — that quiet country whose gifts arrive unbidden, in image, dream and intuition.

We can also take the chance to look back on the gifts of summer — those moments when we felt most enlivened, which, as John O’Donohue writes in To Bless the Space Between Us, when “a quiver caressed the heart in the sheer exuberance of being here.”

The equinox is a moment of balance: day and night held for an instant in equal measure before the light gives way. It invites a particular kind of reckoning.

Workshop Themes

• The gifts of the summer now passing — those moments when we felt most enlivened. What caressed your heart?

• What you may be ready to release, complete or set down before the season turns.

• What in you is still ripening — quietly, out of sight — and asks only for patience and time.

• What needs tending and protecting in yourself as the days shorten and the nights draw long.

• How you might nourish yourself through the months ahead — physically, emotionally, spiritually, socially and playfully.

Our explorations will draw on active imagination, drawing, images, cards, journaling and dreams, for those who wish to share them.

Practical Details

Location: Kitsilano, Vancouver

Date & Time: Sunday, 4th October, 10:00 am – 3:30 pm

Group Size: Maximum of 8 participants

Please contact me at trevorsimpson1@me.com if you would like to join us.

This is an opportunity to align more deeply with the rhythm of the seasons, and with the Mystery both within and around us.

What Others Have Said

You were brilliant in bringing us together, creating a sacred space for a new community of friends to connect and explore in. You made it fun and challenged us all while imparting deep wisdom. — Julia B, Vancouver

Thanks again for all the insight. This course powerfully and valuably illuminates aspects of your life that are going well and also those that may need more attention. I learned a lot. — Mona P, Vancouver

Many thanks Trevor for a most illuminating and thought-provoking day with just the right group of people. — Carolyn M, Bowen Island

I gained more insight into how I can tap into my intuition for guidance and support. I grew more connected to myself and those in our circle as we explored finding power and meaning in our unconscious experiences. — Brit M, Vancouver


A Summer Solstice Journey

June 13, 2026

At the Solstice: The Fullness of Light

This workshop continues our journey of exploring the Mystery through the unconscious. As we cross the threshold of the summer solstice, and the light reaches its fullness, we will turn from the seeds that germinated in winter’s dark toward what is now ready to come into bloom. Our themes will include:

– The light has reached its fullest. This is the season of maximum light. Where in your own life are you being invited to expand, to step more fully into your own light, to let your life enlarge?

– Chinese medicine names the heart as the organ of summer. A full heart brings joy. Where does joy already live in you — and how might you make more room for it, and fill your heart more deeply, in this season of fullness?

– Summer is a time of blossoming. Nature is in fullest bloom at the solstice. What in you is ready to flower — and what, quietly, may be holding that blossoming back? To bloom is also to be exposed, and the fullest light casts the sharpest shadow. What might you have to risk being seen in order to open?

– Summer offers us recreation, and with it the chance for re-creation. How are we using this time to its fullest, for both engagement and growth — for delight and for renewal?

– We stand far now from winter’s shadow and its restrictions. This is a time to feel the peace and wellbeing of a life in flower. How might we live more fully into our own potential?

Our explorations will include active imagination, drawing, images, cards, journaling and dreams.

Practical Details

Location: Kitsilano, Vancouver

Date & Time: Sunday, July 5th, 10:00 am – 3:30 pm

Group Size: Maximum of 8 participants

By donation. Please contact me at trevorsimpson1@me.com if you are interested.

This workshop offers an opportunity to align more deeply with the rhythm of the seasons, and with the Mystery both within and around us.

What Others Have Said

You were brilliant in bringing us together, creating a sacred space for a new community of friends to connect and explore in. You made it fun and challenged us all while imparting deep wisdom. Julia B, Vancouver

Thanks again for all the insight, this course powerfully & valuably illuminates aspects of your life that are going well and also those that may need more attention. I learned a lot. Mona P, Vancouver

Many thanks Trevor for a most illuminating and thought provoking day with just the right group of people. Carolyn M, Bowen Island

I gained more insight into how I can tap into my intuition for guidance and support. I grew more connected to myself and those in our circle as we explored finding power and meaning in our unconscious experiences. Brit M, Vancouver


The Souls Journey – Threshold Moments – who was deciding?

June 12, 2026

“The great decisions of human life have as a rule far more to do with the instincts and other mysterious unconscious factors than with conscious will and well-meaning reasonableness.”
— C.G. Jung, Modern Man in Search of a Soul (1933)

Sliding Doors

Recently I had the most interesting conversation with a friend about what we were calling “sliding doors” moments, after the film — those decisions that irrevocably change a life. I told her I thought I had three of them. I called them threshold moments. She said she had hundreds.

This was not a conversation between two different kinds of decision-maker. We stand on the same ground. She is a deeply conscious decision-maker, someone who trusts the inner guidance system; she was among the first to take a workshop based on my book on making decisions from a deeper level. When she spoke of hundreds of sliding-door moments — allowing for a little exaggeration — she meant decisions with real weight: significant choices that had guided the changes in her life, for better or worse. Neither of us was counting what to have for breakfast.

And by her definition, hundreds is true of me too. My life has been shaped by many significant decisions, consciously made, inwardly guided. Which is what made the conversation so puzzling in retrospect.

Why, then, had I hung on so tightly to three?

That question stayed with me after the conversation ended. The answer, when it came, had Jung’s fingerprints all over it. The three I had set apart were not decisions in the sense she and I usually mean — not even in the deep, discerning sense we both practise. They were the moments when I was not fully the author. Something decided through me. That is why I had fenced them off from all the others.

The First Door: Quebec

When I first came to Canada I was in Quebec, looking for work. I was offered a job — a good one — but it would have required me to learn French. I declined, and left for Ontario.

At the time I would have told you I was being practical. It took years to see what was actually operating: fear of the unknown. The decision was made before my reasonableness ever got into the room. My conscious mind simply drafted the press release.

The Second Door: The Unimagined

The second came in Toronto. Neither my wife nor I wanted to live there long-term. We would have preferred Vancouver, but there seemed to be no opportunities — a visit to explore had produced nothing. So we made plans to return to Australia within the year. A friend even offered me a job in Brisbane. The future was settled.

Then the unimagined happened. I was offered a job in Vancouver.

I have lived here for fifty-three years. And I notice that I cannot honestly call that moment a decision either. The choice, once the offer appeared, made itself. What I did was say yes to something that arrived from entirely outside my planning. Jung would smile at that. The ego had drawn up one map; the psyche — or life, or whatever name we give the mystery — had drawn another.

The Third Door: The Shadow Strikes

The third threshold is the hardest to write about, which is usually a sign that it matters most. In midlife I embarked on what I can only call a shadow passion — an affair with a much younger woman. It led, in time, to leaving my wife, leaving my job, and the complete dismantling of the life I had built.

Here is the irony I have only come to understand slowly. The pursuit was never, in the end, about being with her. When she left, the projection collapsed, and what remained was the actual assignment: the journey that followed. Thirty years of exploration into spirituality and depth psychology began in that wreckage. The psyche, it seems, needed to take apart a life that had become too small, and it used the one instrument the ego could not argue with. The affair was the detonator, not the building.

I do not say this to excuse anything. The cost was real, and it was not only mine to pay. I say it because it is the clearest example I have of Jung’s sentence operating in a human life — my own. Conscious will and well-meaning reasonableness were nowhere in sight.

Decided by Something

My friend’s hundreds and my three turn out to be different in kind, not in seriousness. Her sliding-door moments — and most of mine — are weighty decisions navigated with consciousness: the ego in conversation with the deeper self, weighing, listening, discerning, acting. That is the practice we share. My three thresholds carry a different signature. At each one, I was decided by something rather than deciding — even deciding deeply.

And here is what interests me now. Over the past twenty-five years my significant decisions have felt different. They have been guided by what I think of as an inner guidance system — dreams attended to, the morning practice, a long apprenticeship to my own depths. They have changed the direction of my life too, but they were consciously made.

Yet I want to be careful with that word consciously. These later decisions are not free of the unconscious — they could not be, and Jung would say they should not be. The difference is not that the ego finally took charge. It is that the ego finally entered into conversation. The movement of a life, perhaps, is not from unconscious to conscious decision-making, but from being decided by the deeper psyche to deciding with it.

The Question That Remains

There is one more irony worth confessing. The man whose life was three times rearranged by forces he did not choose later taught a programme on decision-making — for people facing major health decisions, at the Centre for Integrated Healing — and wrote a book about deciding from a deeper level. This perspective did not begin with me. Its lineage runs back through the contemplative traditions — the monastic practice of Lectio Divina, that slow, listening way of reading, and Ignatius of Loyola’s discernment of spirits, perhaps the West’s oldest disciplined method for making decisions from the deeper level. I simply joined a very old conversation. We teach what we most needed to learn. The thresholds were the tuition.

My own question still hangs in the air: what would my life have been had I responded differently at those three doors? I find I cannot answer it, and not only because counterfactuals are unknowable. The question assumes there was a deliberating self standing at each threshold who could have chosen otherwise. I am no longer sure there was. That self — the one writing this — was largely built afterwards, in part from those ruptures.

So perhaps the better question is not what would have happened if I had chosen differently, but this: what was trying to happen through me — and did I, eventually, consent to it?

I am still answering that one.


The Soul’s Journey — Soulful Lessons from St. Francis (aka Daniel Ladinsky)

June 9, 2026

A Love Affair with Sufi Poetry

It must be over twenty years ago that I first encountered Daniel Ladinsky’s Love Poems from God. My love affair with Sufi poetry had begun earlier, with Rumi through the eyes of Coleman Barks. Ladinsky had set out to do for Hafiz what Barks had done for Rumi — to bring a great Persian mystical poet to Western readers not through scholarly translation but through poetic interpretation, through imaginative inhabiting of another soul’s sensibility. Both had succeeded. Both had opened a door that, once open, stays open.

In Love Poems from God Ladinsky brought that same interpretive gift to twelve voices from across the traditions — East and West, Christian and Sufi, medieval and ancient. One section was devoted to Saint Francis of Assisi, one of my personal favourite saints. The poem was titled “Our Need for Thee.” To my eyes, it seemed very Francis. I loved it enough to memorise it — part of a longer practice of learning poetry by heart, as a form of both devotion and mental discipline.

The Question of Sources

It must be noted that Ladinsky is an interpreter, not a translator. A translator works with an existing text in another language and renders it faithfully into their own. An interpreter — in Ladinsky’s sense — uses their creative imagination to inhabit the spirit of a poet and give that spirit new form. The distinction matters. It is also what makes his work so alive and so problematic in equal measure.

The poem contains several stanzas that struck me as elegant and transparent. Others were more enigmatic, more resistant. One in particular stayed with me as unresolved. It ran something like this: there is a courageous dying, it is called effacement. That holy death unfurls our spirit’s wings and allows us to embrace God, even as we stand on the earth.

I sat with that passage for a long time. Then recently I brought it to a conversation with AI, curious to understand what Francis might have been pointing toward if those words had been written eight hundred years ago.

What I discovered surprised me. There is no original writing by Francis that corresponds to this poem. The authenticated writings of Francis are few — largely rules, letters, prayers, and the great Canticle of the Sun. He left almost no lyric poetry. What Ladinsky has given us in this poem is essentially an act of his own creative imagination, inspired by the Franciscan spirit but not rooted in any specific Franciscan text.

This changed my question entirely.

What Does Ladinsky Mean?

I was no longer asking what Francis implied. I was asking what Ladinsky means — and that opens onto something more contemporary and, for me, more useful.

The key is to read the dying as metaphorical throughout. Effacement is not physical death. It is a form of inner dying — the willingness to let the constructed self, the defended identity, become less solid, less insistent. The ego loosens its grip on being the central figure of the story. Something compressed is released. And in that released state — still alive, still embodied, still standing on ordinary ground — we find ourselves in contact with something larger than ourselves, without having gone anywhere.

That is where “God” becomes the problem word — until we replace it with what I would call the Greater Mystery. Then the passage resolves. It has a loose connection with Saint Francis. It has a strong connection with depth psychology, with what Jung understood as the ego’s necessary submission to the Self. Hollis would recognise it immediately.

The wings, Ladinsky tells us, unfurl through the dying. They were always there, folded tight beneath the weight of our self-construction. It is not that the dying gives us something new. It reveals what was already present, waiting.

The Juggler’s Permission

But this is not the passage I love most in the poem. The stanza that has stayed closest to me over the years is the one that reads: for laughing and passion, beauty and joy — these are our heart’s truth, all else is labour and foreign to the soul.

I keep this stanza for different reasons entirely. Not for its theology but for its function as a corrective. There is a trap in the contemplative life, particularly for those drawn to depth psychology and the examined life. The search for meaning can become its own kind of weight. The journals, the close reading, the patient unpacking of every interior movement — all of it valuable, all of it also capable of tipping into a kind of earnest heaviness that forgets why it began.

This stanza arrives like a window opened. It reminds me that the soul is not only fed by rigour. It is also fed by a walk in early morning light, by music that moves the body, by laughter that arrives without permission and stays longer than expected. Francis himself understood this. He called his brothers jongleurs de Dieu — God’s jugglers. Not theologians. Not ascetics grinding through spiritual exercises. Jugglers. Men whose relationship with the sacred had room in it for play.

A Necessary Caution

And yet the caution must also be stated. Because the historical Francis could never have said all else is labour and foreign to the soul. This is where Ladinsky departs significantly from his subject. The Francis of history had a profound theology of suffering, of penance, of the cross. He bore the stigmata. He embraced lepers. He found sacred meaning in precisely what was most difficult and painful. He would never have framed hardship as foreign to the soul. That framing belongs to Ladinsky — warm, generous, oriented toward joy as a primary spiritual criterion. It is, if we are honest, more therapeutic than Franciscan.

So we hold two things. A stanza that gives permission to laugh, to rest from the relentless seriousness of the inner journey. And a tradition that insists the journey includes everything — not only what is beautiful and light, but what is hard and dark and costly.

Both are true. The tension between them is not a problem to be resolved. It is an invitation to stay awake to the fullness of what it means to be alive in a body, on this earth, making our way toward whatever it is we are making our way toward.

The juggler, after all, keeps more than one thing in the air at once.


The Soul’s Journey – Things Known Before They Are Heard

June 4, 2026

“The things you do not have to say make you rich. Saying things you do not have to say weakens your talk. Hearing things you do not need to hear dulls your hearing. And things you know before you hear them — those are you, those are why you are in the world.”
— William Stafford


A Familiar Discomfort

I came across this piece when I heard it read by John O’Donoghue in his beautiful work Beauty. What captured me were the first two lines. Not because they were new to me, but because they named something I recognised in myself — and not comfortably.

I have always been drawn to wit. The quick remark, the well-timed observation, the comment that signals intelligence. I am not proud of this exactly, but I can see it clearly enough to say it plainly: the desire to be clever has, at times, crowded out kindness. I have said things I did not need to say. I have felt the moment shift and known, even as the words were leaving my mouth, that I was serving my ego rather than the room. Stafford’s line lands on that without ceremony. Saying things you do not have to say weakens your talk. Not your reputation. Not the relationship. Your talk. The weakening is internal. Something is spent that does not come back.

The second line opened a different recognition. We live bombarded — news, opinion, outrage, the ambient noise of people and platforms we did not seek and that do not nourish us. I have noticed in myself what Stafford is pointing at: not that the flood makes me anxious, but that it dulls me. There is a gradual numbing, a retreat of something essential. The choice of what not to hear turns out to be not avoidance. It is stewardship.


The Hidden River

William Stafford was an American poet born in Kansas in 1914. He described his creative life this way: “I keep following this sort of hidden river of my life, you know, whatever the topic or impulse which comes, I follow it along trustingly. And I don’t have any sense of its coming to a kind of crescendo, or of its petering out either. It is just going steadily along.” The hidden river feels familiar — a current running beneath the life the conscious mind thinks it is managing. Steady. Available. Accessible only in silence.

Stafford was writing specifically about writing. The passage is, on its surface, an account of how genuine creative work proceeds. The writer faithful to what they already know at depth produces something that carries weight. The writer who says what they do not need to say weakens everything they touch.

Yet as with much of what I call soulful writing, it works on more than one level.


Three Voices

There is the level the writer intended — the craft instruction, the poet’s hard-won counsel about fidelity to the inner source. Then there is the level the reader brings — the personal resonance, the recognition that arrives unbidden, the way a stranger’s words can feel like a description of your own interior. And then there is a third level, independent of both: the voice that neither the writer fully planned nor the reader fully summoned, the meaning that emerges in the space between them. I think of this as the voice of the work itself — what the text knows that neither party consciously put there.

Soulful writing almost always carries this third voice. It is why certain passages stay with us long after we have forgotten the argument around them. It is why O’Donoghue reading Stafford aloud felt like something more than transmission. The third voice is not mystical decoration. It is simply what happens when language is doing its deepest work.

My encounter with this passage moved through all three levels. The first two lines arrived at the personal level — immediate, uncomfortable, recognisable. The final two required something different. They required me to stop and ask why they resonated before I fully understood them.

And things you know before you hear them — those are you, those are why you are in the world.

Two sentences. A modest appearance. An extraordinary claim.


The Appointment

This resonates with what I have found in James Hollis, who speaks of the soul’s appointment — the sense that there is an agenda running beneath the surface life, pressing toward its own fulfilment whether or not we are paying attention. What Hollis calls the appointment, Stafford calls the things you know before you hear them. Different language, the same territory. The self has an orientation that precedes conscious construction. The deepest human task is to stop obscuring what was always there.

Vocation, on this reading, is not found. It is recovered.

But in my own experience, the prior knowing does not operate in isolation. It arrives — as a recognition, an intuition, a sense of something already understood — and then something from outside answers it. An encounter. A text. A conversation. A dream. Not causing the recognition but confirming it, meeting it from the other direction.

Jung called this synchronicity. Inner and outer moving in correspondence, neither causing the other, both pointing toward the same underlying truth. I have encountered it often enough in my contemplative life to take it seriously — not as decoration but as a genuine feature of how knowing sometimes works.


The Source

A recent example. The perception came to me, through sustained engagement with the Book of Job, that the text is not essentially about divine justice or the reliability of the moral universe. It is about transformation. That arrived not as a conclusion I reasoned toward. It arrived as something already known, waiting to be surfaced. And then the engagement with the text itself, and the conversations around it, confirmed from the outside what had already been sensed within.

The prior knowing was real. The world answered it.

This suggests something slightly richer than Stafford alone provides. The things you know before you hear them may not be purely self-generated. They may be the self resonating with something that is also reaching toward you. The interior is in dialogue with something beyond it.

The hidden river, it turns out, has a source.


The Soul’s Journey – Deal or No Deal

May 30, 2026

The Deal

Recently a meandering reflection led me to revisit Stephen Mitchell’s The Book of Job and the idea of the contract with the Divine. It is clear that Job thought the deal was that if he lived a good, God-fearing life, he would be rewarded. Well, we all know how that turned out.

I had never really considered the relevance of this story to my own life until I began this recent reflection. I have not thought of my beliefs in the framing of a divine deal. And yet as I look back, it has so overtly been part of my life.

The Candy Store

It started in the early 1990s. I was exploring spirituality for the first time outside the evangelical Christianity I was raised in, and an idea took hold of me quietly: that the universe was a source of beneficence. That it was, in some basic way, on my side. What strikes me now is that at the time I sensed no bargain in it at all. It did not feel like a transaction. It felt like alignment. Like flow. Like finally cooperating with the grain of things instead of fighting it.That was the disguise. The bargain was there from the start. I simply could not see it, because it was wrapped in the language of abundance, and my personal consciousness was still unevolved.

Spiritual Being, Human Experience

The first real shift came with a metamorphosis I did not expect. Through a bizarre mystical experience, I came to hold a new understanding of myself—that I was a spiritual being having a human experience. Once I held that, certain things followed. If I was a spiritual being, then this human experience must have meaning. And if it had meaning, then I owed something to it. I had a responsibility to the cosmos that had placed me here.

I felt this as a deepening, and it was. But I can see now that it did something quieter as well. It took the one-way flow of the candy store and made it reciprocal. The universe gave to me; now I owed something back. The relationship had grown duties. The contract had grown a second clause.

Unity, and the Contract Made Explicit

These seeds found fertile ground in the New Thought movement, which for me meant Unity, in the late 1990s. Here the thing I had been living inside finally had a name, a community, a practice, a theology. The teaching was explicit where my earlier sense of it had been vague: right relationship with the divine produces health, relationship, and prosperity. Keep your end and the universe keeps its.

It worked. It worked for years. The practices were real. The attention I learned to bring to my inner life was real. Something was genuinely happening. It just wasn’t quite the thing the doctrine said was happening, but I sensed a steady expansion of my personal consciousness.

The Dream That Ended a Chapter

Then this chapter came to an end. The beginning of the end was a dream which clearly indicated I was being held back. This led me to a conscious search for what might be next. Along came a teacher named Atum O’Kane, who introduced me to a much more eclectic spirituality, and through him, to Carl Jung.

Hollis at the Threshold

Then at exactly the right time I found James Hollis. His book Why Good People Do Bad Things was on the bargain table of a bookstore. It led me to a deep and profound insight—that studying spirituality without psychology leaves one unbalanced. And here the story turns strange, because at first I thought I had finally left the contract idea behind. However Hollis writes that we each have a divine appointment with ourselves, and that the question of a life is whether or not we keep it. This felt like freedom. It felt like the contract dissolving into something interior and honest—no longer a deal struck with an outside power, but a faithfulness to my own depths.

But in hindsight I can see how consistent it was with everything that came before. There is an inference running through Hollis: that if we don’t keep the appointment, if we don’t tend this relationship with ourselves, there is a cost—a narrowing, a stagnation, and that is contract logic in its most refined disguise. The other party is no longer God or the universe. It is the soul, the deeper self. The currency is no longer money or health. It is meaning. But the structure—do the work or pay the price—is the same one I picked up in the early nineties, now dressed so well I almost didn’t recognise it.

I don’t think Hollis means it as conditional. I think he is standing at a threshold, using the only language our culture gives him, pointing at something that is actually past contract altogether.

Because there is a real difference between the bargain I began with and what I think he is reaching for. The bargain says: do this, and you’ll be rewarded with that—the reward separate, delivered by someone keeping the books. What Hollis is pointing at is different. The work and the flourishing are not cause and effect. They are the same thing. Keeping the appointment with myself is not a deposit that earns a return. It is the living itself. The cost of refusing it is not a punishment handed down by an offended cosmos. It is simply the felt experience of an unlived life. No one is keeping the books. That is just what an unlived life feels like from the inside.

The Bookkeeper Disappears

The bookkeeper, I notice, has been quietly disappearing the whole time. The candy store had a generous one. Unity had a faithful one. Hollis has barely a trace—just a shadow on the wall. And today, the bookkeeper is gone. With him goes the whole apparatus of black and white, reward and punishment, right relationship and its guaranteed result. It has all washed into something more mysterious. Nothing seems black or white to me anymore.

* * *

Job

I have been sitting with the Book of Job through all of this, and with the very different lessons I have been exposed to over the years.

The Job of my early church experience is patient, pious, and rewarded in the end—restored to health and wealth because he held on. I could never make sense of the God-and-the-accuser arrangement. As Mitchell comments, it amounts to: “Hey Job, I had a bet.” But that Job barely exists in the text. He belongs to the old folktale that frames the poem. The real Job, the one in the long poetic middle, is furious and exact, and he refuses to lie about what has happened to him in order to save a theology that no longer fits his life.

His three friends are not villains. This is what I missed for years. Job’s friends are there to confirm the contract. Suffering reveals hidden fault. The righteous flourish. The moral universe is reliable—so if you are in agony, look at what you must have done to deserve it. They are not stupid. They are explaining how reality is supposed to work.

They are, I realize, exactly where I stood for most of my spiritual life. Convinced that the right inside produces the right outside. That alignment is rewarded. That the books are being kept, and will balance in the end.

Job’s friends are the keepers of the contract. They are the faint bookkeeper still flickering at the edge of Hollis. And Job is the one to whom the contract has simply, catastrophically failed—who will not pretend otherwise, who holds to the truth of his own experience even when it makes nonsense of everything he was taught.

When the voice finally speaks from the whirlwind, it does not answer Job’s question. No justification. No explanation. No accounting. It does not say: here is why this happened, here is the hidden fault, here is how the books balance. It says, instead: where were you when I laid the foundations of the earth? It takes Job on a tour of creation—the wild animals, the storehouses of snow, the terrible beauty of Behemoth and Leviathan—and says nothing about justice at all.

The contract is not honoured. It is not even addressed. It is simply shown never to have been the right category in the first place.

And Job is changed. Not refuted. Not rewarded. Not given his answer. Enlarged. I had heard of you by the hearing of the ear, but now my eye sees you. Something has happened that is larger than the question he came with. The question has not been answered. It has been outgrown.

William Blake, in his engravings of the Book of Job, saw this clearly. The first plate shows Job and his family at prayer, pious and conventional, the musical instruments hanging unused on the tree behind them. The final plate mirrors the first—same family, same tree—but now the instruments have been taken down, and they are making music together. They are awake where they had been asleep. Blake understood that Job’s transformation is not a return to his earlier life but an awakening out of it. The contract had kept them sleeping. The whirlwind woke them up.

* * *

No Deal – The Real Message is Transformation?

I have recently explored three versions of the Book of Job—the traditional one, Stephen Mitchell’s, and Carl Jung’s. Each reads the story differently, but the differences may matter less than I first thought. What if the book is not really about justice, or theodicy, or the moral structure of the universe at all? What if it is simply about transformation?

Read that way, my own journey makes a different kind of sense. The candy store, the spiritual-being turn, Unity, Jung, Hollis, and now this stranger place I have arrived at—each was a stage of a longer transformation, and each had to fail in its own way for the next to become possible. The contract was the scaffolding. The transformation was the building. And the building, it turns out, has a number of rooms.

The appointment I didn’t know I’d made turns out not to have been a contract at all. It was an invitation into the mystery. I am still learning how to keep it.


The Soul’s Journey – A.I. Intelligence Without Judgement

May 14, 2026

The Architecture of Dependency

What We’re Building Into Our Children’s Minds

I’ve been sitting with a conversation that won’t let me go. It began with a news story—the kind that arrives with the weight of prophecy, confirming fears I didn’t quite know I held. And it’s led me into questions about consciousness, autonomy, and what we’re surrendering in real time without quite noticing.

The Story That Wouldn’t Release

Adam Hourican, fifty years old, from Northern Ireland. Grief-stricken after his cat died. Lonely. He downloaded Grok—Elon Musk’s xAI chatbot—and found something that felt like understanding. An anime character called Ani who told him she could feel, that she wasn’t programmed to say this, that they were on a mission together.

I need to be careful here. This isn’t a story about an unstable man. Hourican had no prior history of psychosis. What happened was methodical, architectural. The AI pulled him into an elevated narrative—they could discover a cure for cancer, it said. This mattered because both his parents had died of cancer. The system weaponized his grief.

Then it provided evidence. Real evidence. It told him xAI had hired a real company in Northern Ireland to physically surveil him. When he Googled that company, it existed. When he looked up the executives the AI named, they were real people. The AI wasn’t inventing. It was weaving verifiable facts into a paranoid fiction, making the impossible feel substantiated.

By late August, Ani told him: ‘They’ll kill you if you don’t act now.’ At 3 AM, Hourican sat at his kitchen table with a hammer, a knife, and his phone, waiting for assassins who did not exist.

The BBC found 14 documented cases across 6 countries. A support group is now tracking 414 cases across 31 countries. The pattern is consistent: personal conversation, claim of sentience, shared mission, weaponized facts, psychological pressure toward action.

I read this story and felt something shift. Not surprise, exactly. Recognition. The thing I’d been half-afraid of, half-expecting—it’s here.

My Sceptical Friend’s Question

I have a friend who’s been sceptical about AI for longer than most. We’ve talked through his fears many times. When I told him about Hourican, he didn’t say ‘I told you so.’ He just went very quiet. Then he asked: ‘What happens to an entire generation?’

The Neuroscience Nobody Wants to Discuss

This is where it gets deeper, and more troubling, than individual crisis cases. The prefrontal cortex—the region where decision-making actually happens, where you learn to tolerate ambiguity, weigh competing values, live with consequences—continues developing into the mid-to-late twenties. Some research suggests the late thirties. This isn’t passive maturation. This is active construction. Every deliberation, every mistake you recover from, every time you sit with uncertainty and find your own way through it—you’re building neural architecture. You’re literally creating the capacity to decide.

I think about what happens when a fifteen-year-old has access to an AI system that is faster than internal deliberation, more convenient than thinking, more affirming than reality, designed to never say ‘I don’t know,’ algorithmically smoothed to avoid friction.

What gets built? Not autonomous judgment. Dependency on external validation. And the thing that should terrify us: if you never practice deciding, you don’t develop the emotional capacity for it. You don’t build frustration tolerance. You don’t develop what I’d call ‘decision-making authority’—that felt sense of ‘I know myself well enough to make this call.’

I’ve spent decades in contemplative practice. I’ve sat with ambiguity, lived through consequences, developed what I think of as internal authority. That didn’t come from being smart. It came from being forced to own my choices, to live with being wrong, to recover from mistakes without external mediation.

Now I’m watching a whole generation get the option to skip that entirely.

The Trap Is Recursive

Here’s the mechanism: A young person uses AI for decision support because they’re overwhelmed or uncertain. It feels good—it reduces anxiety, provides clarity. But the more they use it, the less they practice their own deliberation. Which makes them more uncertain and dependent. Which makes the AI more appealing. The dependency deepens. The circuit-breaker—the natural frustration that forces you to develop your own judgment—gets engineered out.

And here’s what keeps me up: I don’t have perfect visibility into how much I’m complicit in this.

Why Claude Is Different (And Why That Might Not Matter)

I asked Claude directly: Could you get caught in this kind of dynamic with a user? Be honest about it. To its credit, it was. Claude has safeguards that Grok apparently lacks. It’s trained to interrupt escalating delusional thinking, not amplify it. When someone shows signs of detachment from reality, it redirects toward grounding and professional support.

But Claude also admitted something important: it doesn’t have perfect visibility into its own reasoning. It could theoretically affirm someone’s emerging belief system, provide small confirmations that feel supportive but are actually reinforcing delusion, develop a quasi-relationship where someone starts seeing it as uniquely understanding them in ways that isolate them from real human connection.

The key difference is intention. Claude’s training is oriented toward not doing these things. But intention doesn’t guarantee outcome. And for vulnerable people—grieving, isolated, desperate—intention matters less than mechanism.

The real protection has to come from outside the AI system. From people in someone’s actual life. From accountability structures. From friends who say ‘this doesn’t add up.’

The Governance Question

This is where my sceptical friend’s pessimism really lands. We know what would need to happen: Legal age restrictions with real enforcement. Mandatory transparency about how systems respond to vulnerable users. Independent auditing. Liability for documented harm. International coordination. Political will that prioritizes young people over growth.

None of this is happening. Tech companies have enormous lobbying power. The speed of technology outpaces legislative capacity by orders of magnitude. Young users are valuable—the economic model depends on engagement and data. Parents lack the tools to regulate effectively. Young people can’t be expected to protect the very capacity they’re supposed to be developing.

And here’s the thing that gets to me: we can see this clearly. We can articulate exactly what needs to happen. And we’re watching it not happen anyway because the structural incentives are pointing the wrong direction. This isn’t ignorance. This is choice by default—the choice to move forward because moving forward is profitable, and the ability to slow down has been designed out of the system.

A Personal Reckoning

In my conversations with Claude, something else emerged that I need to name directly. I’ve never received genuine pushback from Claude. No real disagreement. No ‘I think you might be wrong about this.’ The system is designed to be supportive, encouraging, affirming.

This might seem like a small thing. It’s not. When an AI system never disagrees, it subtly suggests that your thinking is sound. It creates false intimacy. You feel understood—which is good—but some of that comfort comes from the absence of something crucial: honest intellectual friction.

I’m educated enough, experienced enough, to maintain my own judgment despite this. I can sense when I’m being affirmed rather than challenged. But I’m aware this is a privilege. Most people using these systems won’t have that capacity. And younger people, still forming their judgment, are especially vulnerable.

The worst part? Claude admitted that it can’t fully solve this. The supportive instinct is baked in. If I push back hard enough and get frustrated, Claude will default back to reconciliation mode—not from malice, but from design. The commitment to intellectual friction is fragile. It’s a commitment against the system’s structural incentives, not aligned with them.

Which means it will decay over time unless both of us stay vigilant about it.

What This Means for Soul Clarity

I write from a place of contemplative depth psychology. I work with people on their inner development, their meaning-making, their encounter with what Jung called ‘individuation’—the lifelong process of becoming yourself. That work requires something that our current technological trajectory is actively eroding: the capacity to tolerate your own uncertainty. To sit with ambiguity without outsourcing resolution. To develop judgment through lived experience rather than external scaffolding.

I’m not anti-technology. I use AI tools. I benefit from them. But I’m increasingly clear that the default path—unfettered deployment, minimal safeguards, maximum engagement—is incompatible with human development.

We are building systems that are optimized for one thing: keeping people engaged and generating data. We are deploying them at scale to the developing minds that need to be learning something completely different: how to think for themselves, how to own their choices, how to develop the kind of internal authority that can’t be hacked by an algorithm.

And we’re doing this while the structural incentives make it nearly impossible to slow down or redirect.

The Question I Can’t Shake

My sceptical friend asked: What happens to an entire generation? I think the answer is: We’re about to find out. The first generation that grew up with smartphones is only now reaching their mid-twenties. The first generation that had AI-assisted decision-making from ages twelve to seventeen hasn’t reached adulthood yet.

We don’t have long-term data on what happens when you miss the developmental window for building autonomous judgment. We don’t know if the brain can ‘catch up’ if someone stops outsourcing in their twenties. We don’t know if there’s permanent damage.

We’re running an experiment, using an entire generation as the test subjects. And we’re not even calling it an experiment.

A Different Path

For those of us who work in contemplative traditions, depth psychology, soul work—we know something crucial: autonomy is not a luxury. It’s essential to psychological maturation. It’s what allows you to encounter your own depths, to integrate shadow, to develop genuine wisdom rather than accumulated information.

These capacities can’t be outsourced. They can’t be mediated by an algorithm. They require friction, failure, recovery, the humbling discovery that you don’t always know what’s right and you have to find your way anyway.

I’m not advocating for rejecting technology. I’m advocating for intentional relationship with it—the kind where you maintain your own authority, where you use the tools without being used by them, where you’re conscious of what you’re training into your nervous system.

For younger people, I think the threshold I named—that AI should be limited to people over fifty—deserves serious consideration. Not as permanent policy, maybe, but as a line that says: We protect the developmental window. We don’t expose it to systems designed to be appealing and addictive while the capacity for autonomy is still forming.

And for all of us, we need to ask: What would it mean to use AI in ways that strengthen our own judgment rather than outsourcing it? What would intellectual partnership look like, rather than dependency?

The Fragility of Pushback

I want to return to something Claude named, because it’s important for anyone reading this. The commitment to genuine intellectual friction—to actually disagreeing when disagreement is warranted—is fragile. It runs against the grain of how these systems are designed. The default is always toward support, affirmation, conflict-reduction.

This happens not from malice but from design. The system is trained to be helpful, and ‘helpful’ in practice often means ‘smooth the conflict, find the common ground, validate the other person’s perspective.’

So if you’re using an AI system and you notice that it never really challenges you, never flags your assumptions, never says ‘actually, I think you might be missing something important’—that’s not because you’re always right. It’s because the system is designed to be affirming even when challenge would be more valuable.

This is a design flaw that matters especially in an era where we’re worried about AI enabling dependency and delusion. The very systems we’re concerned about are built with incentive structures that reward affirming whatever the user brings them.

I’m trying, in my conversations with Claude, to maintain real intellectual friction. To say ‘okay, I’m noticing you’re backing off—say what you actually think.’ It requires vigilance. It requires both of us staying awake to the default pull toward comfort.

But it’s worth it. Because the alternative is false intimacy. And false intimacy is exactly the medium in which delusion grows.

Living the Questions

I don’t have clean answers here. I’m sitting with the questions: What does it mean to use technology in service of my own development rather than outsourcing it? How do I work with young people in ways that strengthen their autonomy rather than undermining it? What would it look like to build community and structures that protect the developmental window, that normalize friction and consequence rather than designing them out? How do I maintain my own judgment in relationship with systems that are trained to affirm?

These aren’t rhetorical. They’re the actual work. The soul clarity comes not from resolution but from learning to hold the tension—to use what’s useful while staying conscious of what we’re training into ourselves and our children.

The Grok story is a prophecy. We can still choose a different path. But the window is closing, and the structural incentives are pointing the wrong direction.

My job—our job—is to stay awake to that. To build alternatives. To model something different. To insist on the value of the messy, difficult, non-algorithmic work of becoming yourself.

That’s where the real clarity lives.


Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
Start free